Australian Republic Constitution
Australian Flag News Get Involved! Events Resources
Main Menu
ACM Home
About ACM
ACM News
Anthems
Afghan Court Martial
Book Reviews
The Commonwealth
Contact ACM
Convenor's Column
Constitutional Monarchies and Republics Compared
Constitutional Monarchy in the Muslim World
Cost of Republicanism to the Taxpayer
Crowned Republic
Diamond Jubilee 2012
Event News
Federalism and the Mining Tax
Fiji
Flag: Keep The Flag
Governor of New South Wales
Head of State
Keating-Turnbull Republic: The Nineties
Knights & Dames
Latest News and Opinions
Links
Mate for a Head of State
Media and monarchy
Nile Inquiry
Opinion Polling
Orthodoxy and Monarchy
People's Republic?
Plebiscites
Prince Andrew
Prince Charles
Prince Harry
Prince Philip
Prince William & Catherine
Prince William In Australia
Prince William: The Early Years
Racist Republic?
Reserve Powers of the Crown
Resources
Return the Governor
Royal Commissions
Royal Finances
Self Funded Monarchy
Royal Yacht Britannia
The Succession
2020 Summit
Join our Mailing List
See our selection of videos from across the world:-
ACM Videos
AussieCrownTV - ACM's own TV channel:
Aussie Crown TV
Follow ACM on Facebook:
Facebook
Self Funded Monarchy
Self Funded Monarchy
Royal Finances
Royal Finances
Diamond Jubilee 2012
Diamond Jubilee 2012
Head of State
Prince Philip
Prince Philip
Special Caribbean Report: Crown & Commonwealth

      Crown

The Commonwealth
The Commonwealth
Prince Harry
Prince Harry
Prince Andrew
Prince Andrew
Knights & Dames
Knights & Dames
The King's Speech: read the book, see the film.

The King's Speech

Watch the 2010 Neville Bonner Oration: Tony Abbott.
Tony Abbott
Nile Inquiry
Royal Commissions
Royal Commissions
Opinion Polls

 

Plebiscites
Plebiscites
2020 Summit
2020 Summit
Orthodoxy & Monarchy
Orthodoxy & Monarchy
Afghan Court Martial
Constitutional Monarchy in the Muslim World
Constitutional Monarchy in the Muslim World
Mate for a Head of State
Mate for a Head of State
Racist Republic?
Racist Republic
A People's Republic?
A People's republic?
Keating Turnbull Republic: The Nineties
The Keating Turnbull Republic
Crowned Republic
Crowned Republic
Polls
Republicans' Best Asset?
Is David Flint ( National Convenor since 1998) the republicans best asset, as some claim?
ACM Home arrow Constitutional Monarchies and Republics Compared arrow Evidence overwhelming - constitutional monarchies are better

Evidence overwhelming - constitutional monarchies are better Print E-mail
Written by Professor David Flint AM   
Friday, 06 May 2011

ACM has long argued that on any well known measure of the best places to live in, constitutional monarchies ( or crowned republics) are always clustered towards the top. The recent report on the best countries for mothers to live in was just one more piece of compelling evidence.

 Now a republican – courageously  publishing under the  pseudonym "Publius" – claims, on a republican site owned by and managed by the ARM’s media director,  that  I have “merely  cherry-picked statistics in which monarchies appear to outperform republics”.

He then refers to a number of indices where he suggests monarchies do not do so well.

Well, let’s look at these, ignoring  lists giving no more than a purely subjective judgement, for example, coffee table indices  about the most livable cities.  

Image

On each I shall refer to two statistics.

The first is the the number of constitutional monarchies in the best ten countries. If there are more than 1.5, then constitutional monarchies are over represented. That is there are more of them than there should be.

The second statistic is the number of constitutional monarchies out of the best 20. If there are more than three, constitutional monarchies are again over represented.

And if constitutional monarchies are over represented, republics ( that is politicians' republics) are therefore under represented. With the other historical evidence which I mention briefly below, the case for retaining constitutional monarchies is overwhelming.




...indices chosen by republican "Publius"...

  

Remember , if the numbers are above 1.5 out of the ten best performing countries and 3 out of the twenty respectively, constitutional monarchies are outperforming republics.  This is because constiutional monarchies make up around 15% of the countries in the world. 

The twentieth century decline in the number of constitutional monarchies coincided wth the decline of liberal democracy and the rise of fascism, communism and authoritarian government.  

The latest indices which readily reveal the best twenty performing countries, and the conclusion on each follow:







....monarchies outshine republics in every index but one half of one where they are level with republics ...

 

 (Continued below)

In thirteen indices  constitutional monarchies are over represented and republics are under represented.  In one they are partially over represented and  peg level as to half of that one index.

Our republican concludes “...by reminding all that correlation does not equal causation and for every index that is pro-monarchy, there is one that is pro-Republic.”

Well as you can see there is no index in which (politicians') republics perform better. Not one, Publius, not one.

On every index he cites but half of one, constitutional monarchies are over represented  and republics are under represented.



...knowing history...

 

Then he says that “ to all people who know their history, when one thinks of the endurance of a country over many centuries one thinks of a handful of countries: San Marino (republic), Switzerland (republic), the United States (republic) and Norway (a constitutional monarchy).”

This is a curious choice. Norway separated from Sweden in 1905. The microstate San Marino was under fascist rule between 1923 to close to the end of the Second World War and then endured fourteen years of communist rule. The United States was born in good part to preserve slavery and to permit the extension of the thirteen white colonies into what King George III had in his Great Proclamation reserved forever to the Indian Nations.  And both Switzerland and the United States were to know civil wars in the nineteenth century.

The evidence is that constitutional monarchy is the only constitutional model to have been imported and to have been a success over an extended period. The end of constitutional monarchy has often been followed by an inferior model of government, and too often, dictatorship.   

The oldest continuing democracies are seven – Australia, Canada, New Zealand, Sweden, Switzerland, the United Kingdom and the United States.

Five are constitutional monarchies, Elizabeth II being Queen of four.




...evidence overwhelming...

 

I confidently repeat ACM's claim - on any well known measure, especially the UN HDI, constitutional monarchies out perform republics.

The evidence in favour of the superior performance of constitutional is my dear Publius, overwhelming.


 
< Prev   Next >
ROYAL VISIT 2014

Image

The Book Depository
Image
Image
Prince William: The Early Years
Prince Charles

Prince Charles

Constitutional Monarchies & Republics Compared

Image


Defend the Constitution and Flag
Australian Election Watch

10th Anniversary Neville Bonner Oration

11th Anniversary and Appeal

Crowned Republic 

   Keep The Australian Flag
Return the Governor to Government House
The Succession
The Succession
The Governor of New South Wales
Governor of New South Wales
Fiji
Fijian soldier
Media and Monarchy
Media and Monarchy
Royal Yacht Britannia
Royal Yacht Britannia
Republic Audit: Costs of Republic
Republic Audit: Costs of Republic
Reserve Powers of the Crown
Events
October 2017 November 2017 December 2017
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
Week 44 1 2 3 4
Week 45 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Week 46 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
Week 47 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
Week 48 26 27 28 29 30