Australian Republic Constitution
Australian Flag News Get Involved! Events Resources
Main Menu
ACM Home
About ACM
ACM News
Anthems
Afghan Court Martial
Book Reviews
The Commonwealth
Contact ACM
Convenor's Column
Constitutional Monarchies and Republics Compared
Constitutional Monarchy in the Muslim World
Cost of Republicanism to the Taxpayer
Crowned Republic
Diamond Jubilee 2012
Event News
Federalism and the Mining Tax
Fiji
Flag: Keep The Flag
Governor of New South Wales
Head of State
Keating-Turnbull Republic: The Nineties
Knights & Dames
Latest News and Opinions
Links
Mate for a Head of State
Media and monarchy
Nile Inquiry
Opinion Polling
Orthodoxy and Monarchy
People's Republic?
Plebiscites
Prince Andrew
Prince Charles
Prince Harry
Prince Philip
Prince William & Catherine
Prince William In Australia
Prince William: The Early Years
Racist Republic?
Reserve Powers of the Crown
Resources
Return the Governor
Royal Commissions
Royal Finances
Self Funded Monarchy
Royal Yacht Britannia
The Succession
2020 Summit
Join our Mailing List
See our selection of videos from across the world:-
ACM Videos
AussieCrownTV - ACM's own TV channel:
Aussie Crown TV
Follow ACM on Facebook:
Facebook
Self Funded Monarchy
Self Funded Monarchy
Royal Finances
Royal Finances
Diamond Jubilee 2012
Diamond Jubilee 2012
Head of State
Prince Philip
Prince Philip
Special Caribbean Report: Crown & Commonwealth

      Crown

The Commonwealth
The Commonwealth
Prince Harry
Prince Harry
Prince Andrew
Prince Andrew
Knights & Dames
Knights & Dames
The King's Speech: read the book, see the film.

The King's Speech

Watch the 2010 Neville Bonner Oration: Tony Abbott.
Tony Abbott
Nile Inquiry
Royal Commissions
Royal Commissions
Opinion Polls

 

Plebiscites
Plebiscites
2020 Summit
2020 Summit
Orthodoxy & Monarchy
Orthodoxy & Monarchy
Afghan Court Martial
Constitutional Monarchy in the Muslim World
Constitutional Monarchy in the Muslim World
Mate for a Head of State
Mate for a Head of State
Racist Republic?
Racist Republic
A People's Republic?
A People's republic?
Keating Turnbull Republic: The Nineties
The Keating Turnbull Republic
Crowned Republic
Crowned Republic
Polls
Republicans' Best Asset?
Is David Flint ( National Convenor since 1998) the republicans best asset, as some claim?
ACM Home arrow Return The Governor arrow Why Bob Carr ejected the Governor

Why Bob Carr ejected the Governor Print E-mail
Written by Professor David Flint AM   
Sunday, 27 November 2005

In our last column, we pointed out that in his recent bombshell, former NSW Premier Bob Carr had undermined his successor.

The real reason for throwing the Governor out of Government House was not cost. It was not public accessibility. It was far more sinister.

According to Tony Stephens in the Sydney Morning Herald of 8 November, 2005 ("Whitlam leaves past behind with gifts from high time and low"), Bob Carr revealed this at the launch on the previous day of a third edition of Mr Gough Whitlam’s book, The Truth of the Matter.

Image 

Dismissing, without having read it, Sir David Smith’s authoritative book, Head of State, Carr told Whitlam: "Your victory over Kerr is complete. The battlefield has been abandoned."

And then Carr dropped his bombshell.

 

...the real reason.....

He said that one lesson from the dismissal was the potentially corrupting role of the vice-regal office.

This was the reason he had decided the NSW Governor would not live in Government House.

That’s it.

The reason the Governor was thrown out was to diminish the office, and weaken any discretionary power the Governor might have over an errant Premier.

Carr added that the House had been "returned" to the people. Had the specifically purpose built house ever been taken away from them?

Were the people ever asked? They made their views known in Macquarie Street, views which Carr completely ignored.

At the book launch, the former premier then made the extraordinary statement that the "reserve powers" that Sir John used to justify his action did not exist.

The reserve powers do not exist!

This statement would have amazed the great Labor leaders, Curtin, Chifley, Evatt (who even now is still a leading authority on them) and Carr’s illustrious predecessor, and subsequently Governor-General, Sir William McKell.

In 1951, the then Federal Labor Opposition had hoped that Sir John, in exercise of those "non-existent" powers, would refuse Sir Robert Menzies request for a double dissolution in 1951.

The proposition that the reserve powers do not exist would also have astounded Paul Keating and Gareth Evans who spent vast amounts of time trying, unsuccessfully, to codify them.

Everybody, except Bob Carr, agrees the reserve power to withdraw a commission of an errant Prime Minister or Premier well and truly exists.

So what persuaded Carr to make such a monumentally silly statement?

He went on to claim the trappings of vice-regal life had drawn Sir John Kerr to the "delusion" that his role was to exercise real power rather than serve as a ceremonial figurehead.

"Living in the gilded cage of Admiralty House and Government House at Yarralumla, being attended on by security chiefs, ambassadors and visiting heads of state, created the illusion in this man that the paper role of Governor-General had a reality."

So there we have it.

To repeat, the reason the Governor was thrown out was to diminish the office, and weaken any discretionary power the Governor might have over an errant Premier.

It was an attack, a calculated attack, on the checks and balances of our constitutional system.

It was an attack on the constitution.

The 30th anniversary of Whitlam’s dismissal brought out not only Sir David Smith’s profound study of these events.

It has also exposed the dangers of unchecked political power. First, Paul Keating said the Governor- General should have been placed under house arrest, and if he had been Prime minister, he would have done that.

The only other person I have known to hold this view was the last Indonesian dictator. When some people laughed at Mr Keating's words, he insisted that he was serious.

He would have placed the Governor- General under house arrest.

A former and sacked Prime Minister can order a steak, as Mr Whitlam did, but even a Prime Minister in office cannot order the arrest of anyone, as W.M.Hughes once discovered when the police refused to arrest a person who threw an egg at him.

That they would arrest their Commander in Chief, for doing his duty, is highly unlikely.

And then Bob Carr admitted the real, unconstitutional reason for throwing the Governor out of Government House.

As Lord Acton warned in those memorable words, power tends to corrupt and absolute power corrupts absolutely.

Until next time,

David Flint

This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it

To read the Herald report, click here
 
< Prev   Next >
ROYAL VISIT 2014

Image

The Book Depository
Image
Image
Prince William: The Early Years
Prince Charles

Prince Charles

Constitutional Monarchies & Republics Compared

Image


Defend the Constitution and Flag
Australian Election Watch

10th Anniversary Neville Bonner Oration

11th Anniversary and Appeal

Crowned Republic 

   Keep The Australian Flag
Return the Governor to Government House
The Succession
The Succession
The Governor of New South Wales
Governor of New South Wales
Fiji
Fijian soldier
Media and Monarchy
Media and Monarchy
Royal Yacht Britannia
Royal Yacht Britannia
Republic Audit: Costs of Republic
Republic Audit: Costs of Republic
Reserve Powers of the Crown
Events
October 2017 November 2017
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
Week 40 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Week 41 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
Week 42 15 16 17 18 19 20 21
Week 43 22 23 24 25 26 27 28
Week 44 29 30 31
Latest ACM News: -